Muttontown Real Estate, Homes and Condos for sale

All Muttontown homes currently listed for sale in Muttontown as of 05/29/2017 are shown below.  You can change the search criteria at any time by pressing the 'Change Search' button below.

If you have any questions or you would like more information about any Muttontown homes for sale or other Muttontown real estate, please contact us and one of our knowledgeable Muttontown REALTORS® would be pleased to assist you.


Sort By:
Show:
View:  
  Page 1 of 3  
 
$9,900,000
6120 Route 25A, Muttontown NY 11732
6
BEDS
12
BATHS
14,000
SQFT
$707
$/SQFT
7.17
ACRES
1923
BUILT
"Estate Located On Nearly 8 Acres Of Flat, Beautifully Landscaped Gold Coast Property. Every Aspect Of This Extraordinary Mansion Was Meticulously Restored And Remodeled In 2004. Highlights Include Radiant Heat In Kitchen And All Bathrooms, 2 Cottages, Garage Space For 13 Cars, State Of The Art Movie Theater And Recording Studio, Heated Gunite Pool With Pool House, Tennis"
* LISTED OVER 120 DAYS  * PRICE LOWERED - $14,500,000 TO $9,900,000 
$9,900,000
6120 Northern Blvd., Muttontown NY 11732
6
BEDS
12
BATHS
14,000
SQFT
$707
$/SQFT
7.17
ACRES
1923
BUILT
"Georgian Estate Des. & Built In 1922 By Noted Architect James W. O'connor For John F. Bermingham, A Coal Baron & Former Mayor Of Muttontown. This Gold Coast Manor Was Meticulously Restored In 2004 To Its Original Grandeur. Situated On Almost Eight Secluded Acres, This Estate Boasts A Heated Gunite Pool, 13 Car Grge, Prof Recording Studio, 2 Rentable Cottages & Home Theater"
* LISTED OVER 120 DAYS  * PRICE LOWERED - $14,500,000 TO $9,900,000 
$6,300,000
1858 Muttontown Rd, Muttontown NY 11791
5
BEDS
8
BATHS
4.19
ACRES
2009
BUILT
"Grand White Colonial With Old World Charm Set On Over 4 Acres In The Heart Of Muttontown. This Elegant & Eclectic 5-Bdrm, 6.55-Bth Home Has Quality & Class Throughout. With Magnificent Flow & Tons Of Natural Light, It Features High Ceilings, Arched Doorways, Impeccable Details, Sunrm, Elevator, Superior Wrap Around Patio, & Fenced Ig Pool. An Absolute Unparalleled Beauty!"
$5,500,000
8 Clover Ct, Muttontown NY 11732
6
BEDS
8
BATHS
2.88
ACRES
2000
BUILT
"In A Class Of Its Own. Best Location In Pen Mor Estates Behind A Cul-De-Sac With Private Gates And Unquestionably One Of The Most Beautiful Settings In The Village Of Muttontown And All Of The North Shore On Long Island. Resort Style Country Club Backyard Complete With New Infinity Pool, Waterfall, Hot Tub And Night Lights All On 2.9 Acres. Host A Party In Style."
* LISTED OVER 120 DAYS 
$5,348,000
35 Stone Hill Dr, Muttontown NY 11791
7
BEDS
9
BATHS
8,100
SQFT
$660
$/SQFT
2.45
ACRES
2017
BUILT
"Muttontown Stone Hill Gated Lifestyle Community! Coming Soon! Nearly Complete! 8100 Sf Of Traditional Grandeur With Finest Appointments And Luxury Features Including 3 Stop Elevator. Majestically Appointed On 2.45 Acres Of Natural Serenity. Hoa 1390 Monthly Includes Full Ground Care, Snow Removal, 24 Hr Gated Security, And All Amenities. Must See Feature List."
$5,300,000
9 Black Rock Rd, Muttontown NY 11545
7
BEDS
12
BATHS
12,000
SQFT
$442
$/SQFT
0.48
ACRES
1998
BUILT
"Very Large Home Situated On 4.77 Beautiful And Private Acres In Muttontown. The Southern Exposure Provides Abundant Natural Light And Expansive Views Through Walls Of Glass.Gourmet Kitchen , Huge Dining Room Dining And Great Room. 1st Floor Master Suite, 4 Fireplaces,Custom Woodwork,Pool House,Private Horse Trail And Generator."
* LISTED OVER 120 DAYS 
$4,975,000
776 Muttontown Woods Ct, Muttontown NY 11791
6
BEDS
8
BATHS
8,000
SQFT
$622
$/SQFT
4.70
ACRES
2009
BUILT
"Magnificent Young 6 Bedroom Colonial On Almost 5 Newly Landscaped, Manicured Acres. Finished Basement With Gym And Media Room. New Pool, New Tennis Court, New Cabana. Crestron System, Security Cameras, Heated 3 Car Garage. Every Amenity! Jericho Or Syosset Sd. Taxes Successfully Grieved For 2017/2018 And Will Be Reduced."
* LISTED OVER 120 DAYS  * PRICE LOWERED - $5,298,000 TO $4,975,000 
$4,648,000
14 Buckingham Ct, Muttontown NY 11791
7
BEDS
8
BATHS
10,000
SQFT
$465
$/SQFT
0.65
ACRES
2013
BUILT
"Muttontown Stone Hill Estate With The Finest Upgrades, Appointments & Intricate Designer Details. Custom Hand-Painted Ceilings & Walls. Creston Home Smart System. Incredible Amenities Such As Grand Entrance W/Bridal Staircase, Opulent Chef's Kitchen & Butler Pantry Plus Huge Master Suite W/Fireplace & Balcony. Elevator, Radiant Heat + Htd & Cac Garage. Hoa $789.27 A Month"
* LISTED OVER 120 DAYS  * PRICE LOWERED - $4,950,000 TO $4,648,000 
$4,449,000
2188 Kirby Ln, Muttontown NY 11791
7
BEDS
6
BATHS
7,986
SQFT
$557
$/SQFT
2.70
ACRES
2006
BUILT
"Majestic 8000 Sq Ft Center Hall Colonial. Perfectly Situated On 2.7 Acres. , Grand Dual Staircase.7 Bedroos, 5.5 Bath, Gourmet Kitchen,Two Bonus Rooms Extensive Millwork And Crown Moldings,Palladian Windows, In Ground Gunite Pool/ Tennis Court, Pool House Converted To Office Space. Jericho Schools!"
* LISTED OVER 120 DAYS 
$3,995,850
20 Steeple Ct, Muttontown NY 11732
5
BEDS
6
BATHS
8,000
SQFT
$499
$/SQFT
2.56
ACRES
1998
BUILT
"Majestic Brick Colonial Possessing The Expected Fine Finish Dynamics. Quality Construction, Stone Details Throughout, Interior Woodwork Along With A Fantastic Layout Make The Home Both Spacious And Comfortably Intimate. Spectacular Landscape, Gunite Pool, Outdoor Amenities. A Private Estate Setting At The Steeple Court Cul De Sac In The Penmor Farms."
$3,980,000
1766 Oyster Bay Rd, Muttontown NY 11791
6
BEDS
5
BATHS
2.45
ACRES
1967
BUILT
"Excellent Location, Very Desirable Area ,Oasis Of Landscaping Specimen Planting And Classic Gardens Surrounds This Fabulous Home, Beautiful Finished Walk Out Basement To Huge Yard And Fenced Yard"
* LISTED OVER 120 DAYS 
$3,599,999
9 Windsor Dr, Muttontown NY 11753
6
BEDS
8
BATHS
6,400
SQFT
$562
$/SQFT
3.01
ACRES
2000
BUILT
"Immaculate Custom- Built Colonial Home With 6 Bedrooms, 6.55 Baths, Library, Office, Large Eik, Family Rm, Formal Living Room, Beautifully Finished Basement With High Ceiling. The Home Features Cathedral Ceilings, Wood And Marble Floors W/ Radiant Heated Floors. Attached 3 Car Garage, Heated Gunite In Ground Pool. Located In A Private Multi-Mi Community, Jericho Sd."
$3,295,000
50 Westgate Rd, Muttontown NY 11791
5
BEDS
6
BATHS
0.75
ACRES
2009
BUILT
"Better Than New! No Detail Spared In This Masterpiece Residence, With Its Own Fabulous Pool & Pool House. Fully Finished Walk-Out Lower Level Customized W/Home Theatr,Artist Studio, Billards Room, Entertainment Room, Walk-In Wine Cellar And More. Clubhouse With Indoor Pool, Fitness Center And Tennis. Luxury Stone Hill Gated Community And Renowned Syosset School District."
* LISTED OVER 120 DAYS  * PRICE LOWERED - $3,495,000 TO $3,295,000 
$2,998,000
3 Westwood Ct, Muttontown NY 11545
5
BEDS
5
BATHS
6,409
SQFT
$468
$/SQFT
2.78
ACRES
1999
BUILT
"Spectacular 6400Sq. Ft. 5Br, 4.5 Bath All Brick Colonial Perfectly Situated In Muttontown's Brookfield Estates. Formal Lr And Banquet Size Dr ,Gourmet Kitchen With Center Island, Family Room/Fpl, Guest Suite W/Full Bath On Main, Upstairs Bonus Room & Beautiful All Year Round Conservatory, A 3 Car Garage On 2.78 Exquisite And Lush & Totally Flat Acres."
$2,998,000
55 Westgate Rd, Muttontown NY 11791
5
BEDS
7
BATHS
5,645
SQFT
$531
$/SQFT
0.60
ACRES
2008
BUILT
"Muttontown Stone Hill Gated Community. Rare! Master On The Main Floor With Private Loft. Soaring Ceilings Architectural Details, Open Floor Plan, Vaulted Living Room, 2 Story Stone Fireplace Family Room, Brazilian Cherry Wood Floors Gourmet Kitchen Grand Center Island, Breakfast Room, Exercise/Guest Room Bath Dramatic Balcony Overlooks Main Level 3 Bedrooms En Suite Bths"
$2,980,000
3 Buckingham Ct, Muttontown NY 11791
6
BEDS
6
BATHS
5,600
SQFT
$532
$/SQFT
0.62
ACRES
2016
BUILT
"It Is A New 5600 Sqft Custom Built Stone And Masonry Stucco Manor Home In Prestigious Gated Stonehill At Muttontown. 24 Hr. Security, Tennis, Indoor Ig Pool, Clubhouse, Fitness Center. Maintenance Including Full Landscape Maintenance & Snow Removal. This Luxurious Home Has Magnificent Southern Exposure."
* LISTED OVER 120 DAYS 
$2,899,999
2098 Edge Rd, Muttontown NY 11791
5
BEDS
6
BATHS
5,800
SQFT
$500
$/SQFT
2.21
ACRES
2014
BUILT
"Stunning!! & Custom Built..Beautifully Appointed Throughout With Coffered Ceilings, Crown Moldings,French Doors, Marble Bath Flrs. Stunning Chef's Kitchen W/Thermador Appliances And Travertine Flrs. Large Master W/Impressive Cove Ceiling, Gas Fp, Steam Shower, Radiant Bth & 2 Lg Walk In's. Air Bubble Tub, Huge Bonus Rm. Stonework, Salt Water Pool,& Extensively Landscaped"
$2,798,000
15 Buckingham Dr, Muttontown NY 11791
6
BEDS
5
BATHS
0.61
ACRES
2017
BUILT
"Stone Hill At Muttontown Custom Colonial To Be Built In A Culdesac, Wonderful Moldings And Millwork, Beautiful To Be Built Custom Colonial,Gourmet Kitchen & Lavish Baths, Stone Hill Luxury Lifestyle Community, 24 Hr Security,Clubhouse Pool/Gym/Tennis, Full Ground Maintenance & Snow Removal Included, Taxes Not Fully Assessed Approx Hoa $775.00. Pictures Are Samples."
* LISTED OVER 120 DAYS 
$2,500,000
190 Circle Rd, Muttontown NY 11791
6
BEDS
7
BATHS
2.00
ACRES
2006
BUILT
"French Chateau Style Brick Colonial With Incredible Architectural Details."
$2,388,000
5 Bridle Path Ct, Muttontown NY 11545
6
BEDS
7
BATHS
5,100
SQFT
$468
$/SQFT
2.13
ACRES
1986
BUILT
"This Gold Coast Treasure Sun Filled Post Modern Home Situated On Over 2Acres Offers Large Great Room W Vaulted Ceilings W/Fp To A Loft,An Open Layout Kitchen Leads To A Bright Sunny Sunroom,Master Suite On Main Floor,Peacful Setting Backyard W Pond/Fountain/Gazebo,Additional 3800Sqft Living Space On Lower Level,3-Car Garage, Private Cul-De-Sac,Low Taxes,Jericho School"
$2,200,000
10 Howard Dr, Muttontown NY 11791
5
BEDS
5
BATHS
1.49
ACRES
1966
BUILT
"Perfect Location, Sprawling 4000 Sq Ft, 5 Bedroom Ranch On 2 Acres- Open Flr Pln, Has A Great Flow For Entertaining W/ Wall To Wall Windows And Views Of The Htd Gunite Pool And Tennis Ct, Eik W/Wd Cabinets/Granite Counter, Ll Is 3000 Sq Ft W/ Rec Room, Office, Hlf Bathroom, Storage,Circular Driveway, Ig Sprinklers, Jericho Schools."
$2,188,000
93 Sterling Ct, Muttontown NY 11791
5
BEDS
6
BATHS
1.78
ACRES
1976
BUILT
"Diamond Colonial On Approx 2 Acre Park Like Flat Property. Fully Renovated Home, Magnificent Oversized Gourmet Kitchen W/ Gas Cooking. Rich Architectural Millwork Throughout, Built In Bbq, Wet Bar, In-Ground Pool, Fabulous Home For Entertaining, Syosset Schools, Extremely Low Taxes!"
$1,980,000
3 Stoneridge Ct, Muttontown NY 11791
5
BEDS
5
BATHS
5,000
SQFT
$396
$/SQFT
2.02
ACRES
1980
BUILT
$1,695,000
115 W Coachman Pl, Muttontown NY 11791
6
BEDS
6
BATHS
4,004
SQFT
$423
$/SQFT
0.51
ACRES
1987
BUILT
"One Of A Kind/Renovated Spacious 6 Bedroom, 5.5 Bath, Colonial Style Home On Premium 1/2 Acre Lot With Country Club Backyard. In-Ground Gunite Pool With Waterfall, Patio, Specimen Trees & Plantings, Solar Panels, Generator, Security System, Gourmet Kitchen, Wide Plank Brazilian Cherrywood Floors, New Heat & Ac, New Roof & Windows. Heated Garage, Invisible Dog Fence!"
* PRICE LOWERED - $1,798,000 TO $1,695,000 
 
View:  
  Page 1 of 3  
 
Sign up today and you'll be eligible to win an iPad!

 Properties Available
Get Unlimited Search Access
Free & complete access in seconds...
Join now (it's free):
Name (first/last)
 
Email Address
Phone
 
Member sign in:
Email Address
* By signing up today your name will be entered in a monthly iPad giveaway.  You will be notified via email if you win.  No purchase is necessary to participate.