Middle Island Real Estate, Homes and Condos for sale

All Middle Island homes currently listed for sale in Middle Island as of 05/29/2017 are shown below.  You can change the search criteria at any time by pressing the 'Change Search' button below.

If you have any questions or you would like more information about any Middle Island homes for sale or other Middle Island real estate, please contact us and one of our knowledgeable Middle Island REALTORS® would be pleased to assist you.


Sort By:
Show:
View:  
  Page 1 of 4  
 
$549,990
E Bartlett Rd, Middle Island NY 11953
4
BEDS
3
BATHS
2,813
SQFT
$196
$/SQFT
5.32
ACRES
"New Construction, 5+Acre Compound Horse Country, Molding Package, Oak Flooring 1st Floor Choice Cabinets Still Time To Customize Borders On County Park Catheral Pines"
$489,000
Lot 4 Bunker Ln, Middle Island NY 11953
4
BEDS
3
BATHS
2,400
SQFT
$204
$/SQFT
1.50
ACRES
2017
BUILT
"Magnificent New Construction To Be Built On A Private Shared Drive. This Home Boasts 4 Bedrooms, 2.5 Baths, Hardwood Floors, Granite & More. Only 2 Parcels Left Craftsmanship & Attention To Detail Are Evident In Every Touch. Magnificent Symmetry Flows Throughout.Walk To Spring Lake Golf Course"
* LISTED OVER 120 DAYS 
$479,000
6 Chen Ct, Middle Island NY 11953
4
BEDS
3
BATHS
2,200
SQFT
$218
$/SQFT
0.92
ACRES
2016
BUILT
"To Be Built New Construction On Shy Acre Backing Up To Preserved Pine Barrens. 4 Bedroom Colonial Featuring Hardwood Floors & Granite Counter Tops - Too Much To List - Will Provide A List Of Standard Features! Private Settings In A Cul - De - Sac. $1,500. Credit For Appliances. Front Porch Has Been Added To Building Plans!"
* LISTED OVER 120 DAYS 
$475,000
9 Lake Dr, Middle Island NY 11953
4
BEDS
2
BATHS
0.47
ACRES
2009
BUILT
"Nice A Spectacular 80 ' Private Beach - Stunning 455' Lake Front Of Spectacular Views!! Enjoy Boating, Swimming, Fishing & Ice Skating Just Feet From Your Door! 2300 Sq Ft Colonial W/Hdwd Floors, Totally Remodeled In 2009 - 4 Car Garage, Spring Fed Lake!! And Own Your Peninsula!"
* LISTED OVER 120 DAYS 
$469,000
Lot 2 Bunker Ln, Middle Island NY 11953
4
BEDS
3
BATHS
2,400
SQFT
$195
$/SQFT
0.85
ACRES
2017
BUILT
"Welcome To Cedar Ridge Estates! This 2400Sft Denver Model Offers Four Bedrooms, Two & A Half Baths, Hardwood Flooring On The First Floor, Central Air Conditioning, An Outside Entry For The Basement, A Two Car Garage And Many Amenities To Choose From. Meticulous Craftsmanship At It's Finest!"
* LISTED OVER 120 DAYS 
$450,000
47 Half Mile Rd, Middle Island NY 11953
4
BEDS
3
BATHS
2,300
SQFT
$196
$/SQFT
0.45
ACRES
2017
BUILT
"New Beautiful Top Of The Line Home To Be Complete Approx. 6/17.Time To Pick Your Own Colors & Hardwood Cabinets Granite & Wrap Island.4 Lg. Br,3 Br's, W/Walk In Closets Including Master W/Full Bath ,All Hw Floors, Ceramic Tile In Eik & Baths. All Appliances Inc & Washer/Dryer, Anderson Slider W/Built In Blinds,Fbsmt W/Ose,200 Amp Elec,Elec Garage,Pull Down Attic Stairs"
$450,000
45 Half Mile Rd, Middle Island NY 11953
4
BEDS
3
BATHS
2,300
SQFT
$196
$/SQFT
0.41
ACRES
2017
BUILT
"New BeautifulTop Of The Line Home To Be Complete Approx. 6/17.Time To Pick Your Own Colors & Hardwood Cabinets Granite & Wrap Island.4 Lg. Br,3 Br's, W/Walk In Closets Including Master W/Full Bath ,All Hw Floors, Ceramic Tile In Eik & Baths.All Appliances Inc & Washer/Dryer, Anderson Slider W/Built In Blinds,Fbsmt W/Ose,200 Amp Elec,Elec Garage,Pull Down Attic Stairs"
$449,990
78 W Bartlett Rd, Middle Island NY 11953
5
BEDS
4
BATHS
2,800
SQFT
$161
$/SQFT
0.94
ACRES
2003
BUILT
"Ready To Move In 1/2 Mile From Spring Lake Golf Club. 5 Brs, 3.5 Bath Well-Maintained Home On Shy Acre Backing Up To Protected Preserve Offers Plenty Of Quiet And Privacy. Above Ground Pool Being Offered As Gift. Expansive And Open Downstairs With Lr/Family Room, Open Eik With Center Island, Formal Dr, And Junior Suite. Upstairs With Large Master Suite Plus 3 Brs, 1 Bath."
$449,990
30 Lot B Middle Isl Blvd, Middle Island NY 11953
3
BEDS
3
BATHS
1,800
SQFT
$250
$/SQFT
0.46
ACRES
2017
BUILT
"To Be Built Spring 2017! Beautiful Colonial W/Open Concept. Features Stainless, Granite, Hwd, Cac, Full Basement W/Ose, Designer Molding, Raised Panel Doors, Beautiful Private Lot Shares Common Driveway."
* LISTED OVER 120 DAYS 
$430,000
23 Swezey Ln, Middle Island NY 11953
4
BEDS
3
BATHS
1.14
ACRES
1975
BUILT
"State Of The Art Custom Octagon Contemporary Built Home On One Acre Plus Of Private Property. This Home Spares Nothing With Features Like Bamboo Hardwood Flooring With A Touch Of Marbel, Extoic Importated Granite Throughout, Cutomen Cabinetry & Vanities, Designer High End Appliances & Solar For Energy Efficiency. This Is For Sure An Entertainers Delight."
$429,990
N/C Lake Terrace, Middle Island NY 11953
4
BEDS
3
BATHS
0.96
ACRES
2017
BUILT
"New Construction Home! To Be Built/ S/S Appliances,Granite Counter Top, Molding Package, Wood Floors, Carpet In Bedrooms, Cac, 2O0 Amp Service,Master Suite With Master Bedroom,8 Ft Ceilings In The Basement,High Hats In Kitchen, Many More Extra Features!, Off Site Model, Photos Of Previous Built Home"
$418,999
25 Southfield Rd, Middle Island NY 11953
4
BEDS
3
BATHS
85.90
ACRES
1989
BUILT
"Like New, Beautiful Colonial On Large Lot. Featuring 4 Extra Large Bedrooms, 2 Being Master Suites. New Kitchen With Granite And Stainless App. All New Bathrooms New Roof And Pool Liner. Newly Landscaped."
* LISTED OVER 120 DAYS 
$399,999
32 Bailey Rd, Middle Island NY 11953
4
BEDS
3
BATHS
0.55
ACRES
2016
BUILT
"Brand New 2400 Sqft Colonial Boasts 4 Large Bedrms Which Include Master Suit With Walk In Closets & Large Master Bath, 2.5 Baths, Large Custom Kitchen, Den W/Vaulted Ceilings, Fireplace For Those Cozy Nights, 2 Car Garage, Full Basement & Large Property. Come Make This Custom Home Your Palace!! Seller Concession Will Be Considered. Move Right In!!"
$399,990
N/C #2 Lake Terrace, Middle Island NY 11953
3
BEDS
3
BATHS
1.08
ACRES
2017
BUILT
"New Construction Home! To Be Built/ S/S Appliances,Granite Counter Top, Molding Package, Wood Floors, Carpet In Bedrooms, Cac, 2O0 Amp Service,Master Suite With Master Bathroom,8 Ft Ceilings In The Basement,High Hats In Kitchen, Many More Extra Features! 4 Lot Sub Division , Off Site Model, Photos Of Previous Built Home."
$399,990
Lake Ter, Middle Island NY 11953
3
BEDS
3
BATHS
1,600
SQFT
$250
$/SQFT
1.08
ACRES
"New Construction Lake View Acre+ Lots 3 Lot Subdivision Molding Package, Appliance Package ,Oak Flooring 1st Floor Choice Colors & Cabinets High Hat Lighting 200 Amp Electric Still Time To Customize"
$399,990
30 Lot #2 Middle Isl Blvd, Middle Island NY 11953
3
BEDS
3
BATHS
0.69
ACRES
2017
BUILT
"To Be Built Spring 2017! Beautiful Colonial W/Open Concept. Features Stainless, Granite, Hwd, Cac, Full Basement W/Ose, Designer Molding, Raised Panel Doors, Beautiful Private Lot Shares Common Driveway."
* LISTED OVER 120 DAYS 
$394,900
31 Creekside Dr, Middle Island NY 11953
3
BEDS
2
BATHS
1,700
SQFT
$232
$/SQFT
1.08
ACRES
1994
BUILT
"Beautiful, Completely Renovated 3 Bedroom, 2 Bathrooms Colonial. Brand New Eik With Granite Countertops, New Stainless Steel Appliances, Built-In Microwave,Stove/Oven. New Wood Tile Flooring, New Carpets. Designer Showcase Bathrooms! Stone Fireplace. Laundry Room With Washer & Dryer. Situated On Over 1 Acre, Fenced Property. Move In Ready!"
* NEW LISTING 
$379,990
N/C #3 Lake Terace, Middle Island NY 11953
3
BEDS
2
BATHS
0.10
ACRES
2017
BUILT
"New Construction Home! To Be Built/ S/S Appliances,Granite Counter Top, Molding Package, Wood Floors, Carpet In Bedrooms, Cac, 2O0 Amp Service,Master Suite With Master Bathroom,8 Ft Ceilings In The Basement,High Hats In Kitchen, Many More Extra Features! , Off Site Model, Photos Of Previous Built Home."
$379,990
Lake Terr, Middle Island NY 11953
3
BEDS
2
BATHS
0.96
ACRES
"New Contruction Lake View Large Lots, 3 Lots Subdivision Molding Package,Appliance Package, Oak Flooring,Choice Colors,Cabinets,High Hat Lighting 200 Amp Electric Still Time To Customize!"
$370,000
9 Beach Plum Ln, Middle Island NY 11953
4
BEDS
3
BATHS
2,150
SQFT
$172
$/SQFT
0.55
ACRES
2000
BUILT
"Beautiful Home Located In The Preserve Situated On 1/2 Acre Corner Lot! This Home Was The Model/Office For Community So It Has Capped Heating/Ac In Garage. The Open Floor Plan Makes Entertaining Very Easy. Mbr Suite Has Wic, Private Bath With Tub And Shower. Large Yard Offers Bacci Ball Court, Shed, Patio And Stairs To 2nd Level Deck."
* PRICE LOWERED - $379,000 TO $370,000 
$369,888
40 Half Mile Rd, Middle Island NY 11953
3
BEDS
2
BATHS
0.46
ACRES
1973
BUILT
"Beautiful Water Front Property With Great Water Views. 3 Bedroom Ranch With Entry Foyer And Spacious Living Room With Fireplace. 1.5 Baths, Eat-In-Kitchen And Full Basement. Hardwood Floors Throughout. New Roof. Access To Spectacular Lake. Enjoy Swimming, Fishing And Ice Skating. Close To Middle Island Country Club. Great Potential!"
* LISTED OVER 120 DAYS 
$359,000
18 Cedar Ln, Middle Island NY 11953
4
BEDS
4
BATHS
85.90
ACRES
1988
BUILT
"Well Maintained Colonial On Over Sized Property With Gorgeous Gardens & Landscaping. Hardwood Floors Throughout Featuring Living Room W/Fireplace, Formal Dining Room, Eat-In Kitchen W/Sliders To Enormous Deck Overlooking Park Like Backyard. Upstairs Boasts 4 Bedrooms Including Oversized Master Bedroom With Master Bath. Full Basement Is Partially Finished. 2.5 Car Att Gar"
* PRICE LOWERED - $369,000 TO $359,000 
$349,900
40 S Swezeytown Rd, Middle Island NY 11953
4
BEDS
2
BATHS
1,844
SQFT
$190
$/SQFT
0.37
ACRES
1972
BUILT
"Updates Everywhere! Roof, Gutters, Windows, Vinyl Siding, Stunning Kitchen W/Stainless Appliances, 42 Cabinetry & Granite Countertops! Breakfast Bar! Hardwood Floors Throughout Living Areas. Both Baths Updated A Couple Years Ago - Clean & Bright! Tile Floors & Plumbing In Place For Summer Kitchen. 2 New Wall Mount Ac Units. 200 Amp Electric. 1 Car Garage. Updated Driveway"
$349,900
N/C Swezey Ln, Middle Island NY 11953
4
BEDS
3
BATHS
1,900
SQFT
$184
$/SQFT
1.00
ACRES
2017
BUILT
"Beautiful Charming Victorian Featuring 4 Bedrooms, 2.5 Baths, Hardwood Floors - Open Concept On A 1 Acre!"
 
View:  
  Page 1 of 4  
 

Explore Middle Island Communities

Choose a community below to view homes, condos and Real Estate for sale.

Sign up today and you'll be eligible to win an iPad!

 Properties Available
Get Unlimited Search Access
Free & complete access in seconds...
Join now (it's free):
Name (first/last)
 
Email Address
Phone
 
Member sign in:
Email Address
* By signing up today your name will be entered in a monthly iPad giveaway.  You will be notified via email if you win.  No purchase is necessary to participate.