Bay Shore Real Estate, Homes and Condos for sale

All Bay Shore homes currently listed for sale in Bay Shore as of 05/29/2017 are shown below.  You can change the search criteria at any time by pressing the 'Change Search' button below.

If you have any questions or you would like more information about any Bay Shore homes for sale or other Bay Shore real estate, please contact us and one of our knowledgeable Bay Shore REALTORS® would be pleased to assist you.


Sort By:
Show:
View:  
  Page 1 of 9  
 
$3,995,000
69 Lawrence Ln, Bay Shore NY 11706
5
BEDS
9
BATHS
7,000
SQFT
$571
$/SQFT
1.76
ACRES
1922
BUILT
"Summer On The Water Party Peninsula Offers The Ultimate In Waterfront Living. This Magnificent Tudor Estate Is Located On A Meticulously Landscaped 1.76 Acre Private Peninsula Overlooking The Great South Bay. This Lifestyle Home Includes 900 Feet Of Bulkhead Waterfront With 120 Feet Of Protected Dock For Yacht + Tender. 10 Min To Fire Island Inlet."
$2,499,000
75 Garner Ln, Bay Shore NY 11706
5
BEDS
6
BATHS
6,000
SQFT
$416
$/SQFT
1.80
ACRES
1997
BUILT
"Waterfront, Oconee Association, 2 Acres, 6000 Sf Estate Home, 400 Sf Pool Cabana, Beautiful Free Form Gunite Pool W/Spa, 3 Car Attached Garage, 5 Bedroom, First Floor Master Suite, Gated Driveway, High Ceilings, Old World Moldings & Trim, Radiant Heating, Media Room, Traditional Paneled Library W/Bar, Open Very High End Kitchen/Family Room With Custom Entertainment Center"
* LISTED OVER 120 DAYS  * PRICE LOWERED - $2,990,000 TO $2,499,000 
$1,699,000
125 Awixa Ave, Bay Shore NY 11706
5
BEDS
5
BATHS
1.00
ACRES
1975
BUILT
"Spectacular Bay Front Home Overlooking The Gsb & Views Of Fi Light House. This Sprawling 5800 Sq Ft Expanded Ranch Is Situated On Over An Acre Of Property. 680 Ft Of Bulk Head W/ Private Boat Slip Approx 200Ft Long, Inground Pool Surrounded By Lush Landscape. New 3 Zone Cac, New Furnace, 4 Zone Heat, Full Sauna, Den W/Built In B-Bque, Generator, 9 Zone Igs, Sec Sys"
$1,499,000
170 S Penataquit Ave, Bay Shore NY 11706
3
BEDS
3
BATHS
3,767
SQFT
$398
$/SQFT
2.75
ACRES
1985
BUILT
"This Spectacular Bay Front Contemporary Is Situated 2.75 Acres With 1000 Feet Of Bay And Canal Frontage. The Expansive Property Features Total Privacy With Two Cut In Marinas, Gazebo And Boat House. The Home Was Untouched By Sandy And Features An Open Style Living Plan With Views From Every Window."
* LISTED OVER 120 DAYS  * PRICE LOWERED - $1,550,000 TO $1,499,000 
$1,390,000
42 Garner Ln, Bay Shore NY 11706
6
BEDS
6
BATHS
5,000
SQFT
$278
$/SQFT
2.00
ACRES
1940
BUILT
"Waterfront. Traditional English Tudor On 2 Acres Of Estate Grounds In Exclusive O-Co-Nee Estates. New Roof,Heating,Cac, And Patio. New 125 Ft Of Bulk-Heading And Dock( Water,Power,Lights) Deep Water. Detached 2 Car Garage With Maid's Quarters.Detached Boathouse With Captain's Quarters And Private Driveway To Waters Edge. Igs W/Private Well. Homeowners Assocation"
* LISTED OVER 120 DAYS  * PRICE LOWERED - $1,420,000 TO $1,390,000 
$1,199,000
23 Garner Ln, Bay Shore NY 11706
5
BEDS
6
BATHS
2.30
ACRES
1914
BUILT
"2.3 Acre Estate In The Desirable O-Conee Association Featuring 5 Beds, 4.55 Bath, Ef, Flr W/ Fp, Fdr, Library, Sunporch, Master Suite, New Gourmet Eik Open To Great Room With Vaulted Ceiling And Fp. Slate Patio Overlooks The Rose Garden And Great Lawn. Private Free Form Gunite Pool, Tennis Court, All Sports Court And Detached Garage. Do Not Miss This Family Retreat!"
* LISTED OVER 120 DAYS  * PRICE LOWERED - $1,275,000 TO $1,199,000 
$1,195,000
19 Captains Walk, Bay Shore NY 11706
4
BEDS
3
BATHS
0.14
ACRES
1984
BUILT
"Spectacular Location With Panoramic Views Of Lighthouse & Bridges. Completely Renovated & Expanded, Spacious 4 Br, Marble Floors. Windows Galore. Huge Kitchen & Bar. Master Br On 1st Floor. 2 Car Garage. Plenty Of Storage."
* LISTED OVER 120 DAYS 
$1,095,000
105 Awixa Ave, Bay Shore NY 11706
5
BEDS
4
BATHS
5,506
SQFT
$199
$/SQFT
1.01
ACRES
1948
BUILT
"Please View The Virtual Tour Attached For Full Features And Additional Pictures. Incredible 6 Bed,4 Bth Colonial Beauty Boast 5506 Sq Ft Of Living. Magnificent Setting W/150' Bulk Head, 20X40', Boat Slip, Dry Boat Hse, Outdoor Kitchen And Shed. Sprawling Park Like Lawn With Spectacular Views Of The Great South Bay. Just Over 1 Acre Lot Size."
* LISTED OVER 120 DAYS  * PRICE LOWERED - $1,250,000 TO $1,095,000 
$999,000
87 S Penataquit Ave, Bay Shore NY 11706
9
BEDS
4
BATHS
6,000
SQFT
$166
$/SQFT
1.26
ACRES
1880
BUILT
"Welcome To Seaward! This Exquisite, One-Of-A-Kind Queen Anne Victorian, Circa 1880, Is A Historic Treasure W/ Stunning Appointments Thru-Out. A Magnificent 3 Story Home Featuring Mahogany Inlaid Flrs, 9 Fps, 2 Staircases, Stunning Wood-Paneled Rms & Mouldings, Wrap-Around Veranda, Stained/Lead Glass, Spectacular Captains Quarters, Much More! An Entertainer's Dream!"
$999,000
100 Awixa Ave, Bay Shore NY 11706
5
BEDS
3
BATHS
2.70
ACRES
1926
BUILT
"What An Opportunity! Incredible Charm Throughout This Estate..All Spacious Rooms, A Wonderful Open Floor Plan..Can All Be Made Into Your Dream Home! Also Suited For Builder W/ Possible Subdivision Of Grounds. 2.5 Car Detached Garage As Well As Additional Structure (Previous Cottage) On Private Grounds. The Possibilities Are Endless! Owner Financing Considered."
* LISTED OVER 120 DAYS  * PRICE LOWERED - $1,100,000 TO $999,000 
$985,000
1420 &1424 N 5th Ave, Bay Shore NY 11706
4
BEDS
5
BATHS
1.23
ACRES
1940
BUILT
"These Two Homes Are On Property Consisting Of 53,578 Sq. Ft. Owner Will Sell Subject To Zoning Change. Property Has Frontage On Both N .Clinton And 5th Ave. Owner Wants To Hold Mortgage."
* LISTED OVER 120 DAYS 
$939,000
32 Lawrence Ln, Bay Shore NY 11706
6
BEDS
4
BATHS
3,800
SQFT
$247
$/SQFT
0.57
ACRES
1922
BUILT
"Inspired By Country French Architecture, This Grand Colonial Is Located In The Waterfront Community Of O'conee Estates W/ Assoc. Mooring,Beach & Security. 3Fpl, Fr.Doors, Detailed Mouldings, Mahogany Inlay Floors,Library W/Raised Panel Walls, Gorgeous Kit & Fam Rm Overlooking Lush Gardens, Servt Staircase, Walk-Up 3rd Flr, Upper Level Balconies. Rear Yard/ Gazebo & Pergola"
* PRICE LOWERED - $959,000 TO $939,000 
$899,000
66 Mowbray Ave, Bay Shore NY 11706
3
BEDS
3
BATHS
2,000
SQFT
$450
$/SQFT
0.33
ACRES
1962
BUILT
"Wow! Big Opportunity To Own This 3 Bd/2.5 Bath Waterfront Ranch With 13 Dock Slips On 180Ft Bulkhead On Wide Canal. Igs/P. Cul-De-Sac. Needs Some Updating."
$789,990
57 Maple Ave, Bay Shore NY 11706
5
BEDS
3
BATHS
0.43
ACRES
1934
BUILT
"Beautifully Restored Turn Of The Century Victorian The Heart Of Bay Shores Historical District. Charming Wood Barreled Ceiling Front Porch. Recent Custom B'yard Hardscaped Walks & Patios Paver Walkways & D'ways, 3 Levels Of Living, W/ Modern Kit & Bth. Parking For Up To 15 Cars. Near Ferries,Fine Dining,Water Views, Marina, State Of The Art Hospital, Lirr,Shopping & More"
$720,000
917 Gardiner Dr, Bay Shore NY 11706
5
BEDS
4
BATHS
3,617
SQFT
$199
$/SQFT
0.94
ACRES
1967
BUILT
"Greatly Expanded And Updated 3,600 Sq' Ponderosa Ranch With Gleaming Wood Floors, 5 Bedrooms, 3.5 Baths, Granite And Ss Kitchen W Ceramic Floor, Huge Great Room, 2 Car Detached Garage All On 1 Acre Property In Southwood Estates."
* LISTED OVER 120 DAYS  * PRICE LOWERED - $730,000 TO $720,000 
$695,000
152 Awixa Ave, Bay Shore NY 11706
4
BEDS
3
BATHS
0.45
ACRES
1963
BUILT
"Stunning Tuscan Style Home In Very Prestigious & Historic Penataquit Point, W/ Waterviews From Brs. Featuring Newer Kitchen & Dining Rm, Lg. Family Rm. Leading To Sunny 3 Season Rm.For Friends & Family Gatherings. Welcoming Backyard W/ Plantings, Pond, Bocce Court, Lg. Paver Patios, 12V. Light Scape & Security System. Custom Moldings, Ceramic & Hw. Floors, New Hvac, Cvac."
$650,000
116 Harbour Ln, Bay Shore NY 11706
3
BEDS
3
BATHS
2,923
SQFT
$222
$/SQFT
0.10
ACRES
1977
BUILT
"Beautiful Expanded Atlantis Townhome In Gated Admiralty Community. Located Next To Nature Conservancy. Entry,Fdr,Flr W/Frplc,Updtd Bth,Renovated Kitchen,Office,Den W/Built-Ins1-Car Garage.Up:Mbr W/Balcony,Sit Rm,2 Wic Closets And Access To Storage Attic,Updted Fbth, 2 Guest Br,Fbth. Private Location.Htd Pool,Clbhse W/Gym & Sauna,3 Har-Tru Tennis Cts,Gardens,Marina"
* LISTED OVER 120 DAYS 
$649,000
161 Anchor Ln, Bay Shore NY 11706
3
BEDS
4
BATHS
0.10
ACRES
1977
BUILT
"End Atlantis Unit! This Private Expanded Colonial Boasts Of Gorgeous Southern Views Of The Great Lawn And Lake. Possible First Floor Master, Plus 3 Bedrooms, 3.5 Baths, Custom Eik, Dining/Living Great Room, & Office. Amenities Include: 24Hr Guard Gated, Deep Water Docking, Tennis, Pool, Clubhouse Activities, &160 Pristine Acres Leading To Great South Bay!"
* NEW LISTING 
$649,000
1106 Namdac Ave, Bay Shore NY 11706
4
BEDS
3
BATHS
0.25
ACRES
2016
BUILT
"Dramatically Designed Home New Construction Completed In 2016. Beautifully Appointed Home Boasts Open Floor Plan, Custom Designed Center Island Kitchen, Double Sided Gas F/P, Family Room, Dr,Lr, Master Suite,F/P,/Spa Bath, Family Size Bedrooms. Custom Mill Throughout, Beautiful Oak Hardwood Floors, High End Finishes, Energy Efficient,Nest Therm.Central Vac, West Islip Sch"
$645,000
35 E Admirals Dr, Bay Shore NY 11706
3
BEDS
3
BATHS
2,669
SQFT
$242
$/SQFT
0.11
ACRES
1977
BUILT
"Stately Elegant Townhome In Gated Admiralty Community. Entry Foyer Leading To Updtd Kitchen,Lndry Area,Den/Office,Living Rm W/Frplc,Dr Leading To Outdoor Patio W/Exquisite Gardens.Powder Room. 2C-Gar. Freezr. Up: Mbr W/Sit Rm W/Marble Frplc,Balcony, Fbth W/Jetted Tub, 2 Guest Br, Fbth. Smart Home Features Nest Thermostat. Anderson & Pella Windows.Gas Heat.Custom Moldings."
* LISTED OVER 120 DAYS  * PRICE LOWERED - $659,900 TO $645,000 
$619,000
701 Montauk Hwy, Bay Shore NY 11706
5
BEDS
4
BATHS
3,295
SQFT
$188
$/SQFT
0.08
ACRES
1972
BUILT
"This Amazing Colonial Has It All! Situated On Pristine 1 Acre Property , 5 Bdrms, 3.5 Baths, Eik W/Double Oven, Ss Appl., Den, Office, Attic, Full Basement. Beautiful Hardwood Flrs, New 2 Zone Cac, 10 Zone Igs, 2 Car Garage. Perfect For Home Or Office."
* LISTED OVER 120 DAYS  * PRICE LOWERED - $649,000 TO $619,000 
$599,999
142 Anchor Ln, Bay Shore NY 11706
3
BEDS
3
BATHS
2,923
SQFT
$205
$/SQFT
0.09
ACRES
1978
BUILT
"Exp. Atlantis Town Home @ The Admiralty. Pristine 230 Acre Waterfront Property W/24 Hr Gatehouse, Lush & Manicured Sprawling Estate Style Property On Great South Bay W/ Pool, Gorgeous Clubhouse, Deep Water Marina W/ Access To Great South Bay, Har Tru Tennis Courts, Flower Gardens, Ponds, Private Beach, Nature Trails & More. Town Home Offers 3 Bedrooms, 2.5 Bathrooms"
$598,000
22 Admirals Dr, Bay Shore NY 11706
2
BEDS
2
BATHS
0.10
ACRES
1977
BUILT
"Welcome To This Spectacular & Pristine Commodore Ranch In The Gated Admiralty Community. This 2-Bedroom, 2-Full Bath Features Lr/Dr W/Fplc, Open Kitchen W/Ss Appliances & Wine Refrigerator, Walk-Up Attic, And Den. Perfect For Entertaining Inside And Outside. Amenities Include: Clubhouse W/Gym & Full Kitchen, Har Tru Tennis Cts, Ig Pool, Marina, And Beach. Bay Shore Sd# 1."
$580,000
301 Captains Way, Bay Shore NY 11706
2
BEDS
2
BATHS
2,138
SQFT
$271
$/SQFT
0.10
ACRES
1978
BUILT
"Beautiful Expanded End Unit Commodore Model. Entry With Skylight, Eat In Kitchen, Den W/ Skylight, Livingroom With Fireplace And Open Dining Room Area Perfect For Entertaining. Master Bedroom Suite With Master Bath, Second Bedroom With Bath Jacuzzi And Skylight. Porcelain Tiled Floors, Gas Heat, One Car Garage, Amenities Include Pool, Marina, Tennis, Clubhouse, Gym."
* PRICE LOWERED - $595,000 TO $580,000 
 
View:  
  Page 1 of 9  
 
Sign up today and you'll be eligible to win an iPad!

 Properties Available
Get Unlimited Search Access
Free & complete access in seconds...
Join now (it's free):
Name (first/last)
 
Email Address
Phone
 
Member sign in:
Email Address
* By signing up today your name will be entered in a monthly iPad giveaway.  You will be notified via email if you win.  No purchase is necessary to participate.